For modern tool steel these modern stones do offer a convenient alternative to water stones. On the other hand oil should be used on arkansas stones and norton india stones.
Arkansas Black Surgical Sharpening Stone Black Arkansas Sharpening
Cleaning An Old Oil Stone Norse Woodsmith
Arkansas Sharpening Stones For Sale Osograndeknives
Water should be used on diamond stones which can also be used dry most synthetic man made whetstones ceramic stones and japanese water stones.
Arkansas stone oil or water. If you buy these i suspect youll either replace them soon or just give up on oil stones. The three most common types of sharpening stones are oil stones water stones and diamond stones. Using arkansas stones dry is not recommended.
Diamond stones dont need flattening or soaking in water. I like smiths on trans and black arkies. For the most part they are not labeled.
Water doesnt seem to float the swarf off very well and the stones seem to get clogged. In general for fast cutting a water displacer can be ok wd 40 etc or even good for the mid stones. These india stones are pre soaked in oil so trying to use water with them would be ineffective.
Understanding the differences in materials. Theres no legal definition of hard black arkansas stone so any black colored rock from arkansas can be sold as hard black arkansas. Selecting a sharpening stone.
One says oil stone. Your sharpening stone needs. The coarse stones keep their pores clear best with a light oil like light mineral oil and the fine stones work finest with a light oil though a good stone with wd40 will also make a superb edge off of a good truly hard stone.
Some are labeled with india or arkansas. For my needs water stones are a bit of a drag. I have no idea if i should use water or oil or what india vs.
Some of them are very dirty and dont seem like they would cut well without a little tlc. A few of them are double sided too. Weighs in on the question of using oil or water on your sharpening stones.
I like norton oil on the coarser arkies like washita soft and hard arkies. Got plenty of ballistol but still havent tried it on stones. Arkansas stones do wear and can develop an uneven surface with over time.
Oil stones loose out here as theyre just too slow for hard and thick irons. Do arkansas stones loose their flatness with use. When used without water or oil arkansas stones will become clogged with the waste material from sharpening which will make them work dramatically more slowly.
I use it when burnishing a new or re lapped stone. Each of these stones has its own advantages that can help users achieve their sharpening goals. I got some assorted honing stones from a yard sale.
As a frequent advocate of oil stones your selection is one that kinda torques my jaw.
Stone Grades 101 Dan S Whetstone
Difference In Sharpening Stone Materials
Natural Whetstone Company Products Sharpeners Page 1